Back to Projects Share on LinkedIn Share on Twitter Facebook Share
Historic church construction

Burke Lutheran Church

Madison, WI
Services: New Construction, Remodel
Architect: Cashman Associates - Sun Prairie, WI

Three-phase historic church construction project included relocating a 121 year old, 185 ton sanctuary

NCI-Roberts Construction completed three phases of construction for Burke Lutheran Church, an Evangelical Lutheran Church of America congregation in Madison, Wisconsin, with Norwegian history going back to 1851 and a membership going back multiple generations.

The church’s onsite cemetery limited its ability to expand from its original footprint and meant parking was further away than desired. Plus, portions of the church were not accessible. After decades of weighing new construction and historic preservation options, the congregation found, in the words of one member, an “ideal mix of honoring our past yet facing the future.”

Final result of three-phase historic church construction and renovation
Side view
New zero-step entrance into the vestibule
Kitchen with ample workspace and pantry for storage
Fellowship hall
Fireside room
Nursery with bathroom
The organ was dismantled, cleaned and moved to its new space
A view of the church taken from its previous location
The site where the church was originally located

Phase one: new construction

First, NCI-Roberts constructed a new single-story, 5,830 square foot structure behind its cemetery. The floorplan incorporated fellowship space, a warming kitchen with pantry, choir room, nursery, fireside room, offices, bathrooms, and rooms for files, mechanicals, and storage. Above-window details tie into the original structure’s design. The space was the congregation’s first fully accessible building, complete with a new driveway and parking lot, and a covered zero-step entrance into the vestibule.

Just two weeks of services were held in the new fellowship hall in early 2020 before the COVID-19 pandemic restricted in-person gatherings and required the church to pivot use of the fellowship hall to a virtual worship “studio.”

Church before
Church classrooms and fellowship before
Sanctuary before
Setting trusses
Windows and shingles installed
New church structure

Phase two: relocation

Phase two was relocating the original church, built in 1899. NCI-Roberts demolished a portion of the existing church constructed in 1964 containing office and education space and used the bricks from it for repairs. Then together with Heritage Movers, the contractor raised the remaining structure with roughly 20 jacks onto dollies about five feet high and moved it inch-by-inch to a new foundation next to the new facility. The contractor also removed and prepared stained glass windows from the original structure for re-installation, among other efforts to restore and maintain the memories it holds for the congregation.


Phase three: uniting new and old

Finally, NCI-Roberts relocated the original church and connected it to the phase one facility with a 658 square foot addition that serves as a new sacristy and organ room.

Once the original structure was in its new location, the contractor began renovation of its interior. To enlarge the sanctuary space, two walls of the former organ room and a staircase were removed. NCI-Roberts improved accessibility by adding a ramp up to the altar, which required removal of all but a post of a former sacristy wall. The post was encased by a column, custom constructed to match three existing columns on the altar.

Accessibility was also improved by a new pew layout that created a center aisle for the first time in the church’s history, as well as two side aisles. The addition of a center aisle was important to the congregation for weddings and other significant services.

Another meaningful change was relocation of an original stained glass window to the new vestibule.

Doors were relocated, and flooring and drywall were patched.

Stained glass windows in the narthex
Sanctuary with new center aisle
The sanctuary includes the original pews
The new pew layout improves accessibility
New sacristy

Construction was completed in tandem with the lifting of some pandemic restrictions, and Burke Lutheran Church held its first service in the new, original church the Sunday before Easter in 2021.

Like What You See?

Let's get in touch and chat about your next project.

Contact Us
Like What You See?

Let's get in touch and chat about your next project.

Contact Us
Hungry For More?

Check out another case study or view more projects.

Case Study Heartland Church
Case Study Dane County Humane Society
Case Study Wil-Mar Neighborhood Center